Recommendations & Conclusions
33 items
2
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The Department does not yet have a clear plan in place for a national emergency stockpile for any future pandemic. The stockpile held by the Department was invaluable for the first few months of the COVID-19 pandemic but it does not currently have a plan for the level or composition …
Read more
The Department does not yet have a clear plan in place for a national emergency stockpile for any future pandemic. The stockpile held by the Department was invaluable for the first few months of the COVID-19 pandemic but it does not currently have a plan for the level or composition of the desired stockpile for any future pandemics. The Department was limited in its response to COVID-19 by the lack of domestic production of PPE and it has advised that it is working on strengthening domestic PPE supply chains. As well as the significant volumes of PPE it purchased, and is now disposing of, the Department has entered into contracts for both COVID-19 vaccines and COVID-19 medicines which commit it to procure future stock. It recognised impairments in 2021–22 of £1.7 billion for COVID-19 vaccines and £1.8 billion for COVID-19 medicines with a limited shelf life which it now does not expect to use. 6 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts Recommendation 2: The Department should develop and implement a clear, cost-effective plan for a national emergency stockpile to respond to any future pandemic.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it has a clinical countermeasure program, is setting up a UK-Moderna partnership for vaccine manufacturing, and has signed a service level agreement with SCCL for stock rotation. It is also working with SCCL on PPE volumes and preparing advice.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
3
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
There was a fundamental absence of formal governance arrangements at UKHSA and the Department failed to respond to the heightened risks of setting up a new and complex organisation at pace. UKHSA was created on 1 April 2021 with unsatisfactory governance arrangements. Although the Non-executive Chair and Chief Executive were …
Read more
There was a fundamental absence of formal governance arrangements at UKHSA and the Department failed to respond to the heightened risks of setting up a new and complex organisation at pace. UKHSA was created on 1 April 2021 with unsatisfactory governance arrangements. Although the Non-executive Chair and Chief Executive were in post from 1 April 2021, no more non-executive directors were appointed until April 2022, one month after its first year-end. The lack of governance resulted in inadequate scrutiny and assurance of UKHSA’s operations. The Chief Executive was appointed into a role, as Accounting Officer and Chief Executive, of which she had no previous experience and relied heavily on the Non- executive Chair for support stepping into this position. The Non-executive Chair’s role therefore shifted from one which should have been scrutinising management to one of an executive member of the organisation. The Department failed to support UKHSA, taking a light touch approach to the governance arrangements in place, identifying risks but failing to make any arrangements to mitigate these issues. In addition, the Department did not provide UKHSA with a budget until after the year end. UKHSA’s Non-executive Chair told us that this meant that the function of the new organisation remained uncertain and that the mandate of any non-executives would not have been sufficiently clear. Recommendation 3: The Department must work with UKHSA to ensure that the governance arrangements at UKHSA are assessed, rectified and that the remaining vacancies within its governance structure are resolved as a matter of urgency.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states UKHSA completed non-executive recruitment by April 2022, established corporate governance and committees by September 2022, and appointed an Audit and Risk Committee Chair in April 2023. A GIAA review was completed, and identified actions to improve governance were completed by March 2023 …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
4
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
UKHSA had a fundamental weakness in financial controls and processes which resulted in it being unable to prepare auditable accounts. On 1 October 2021, the day that it became operational, UKHSA implemented a new IT accounting system and transferred the operations of its three predecessors onto this new system. At …
Read more
UKHSA had a fundamental weakness in financial controls and processes which resulted in it being unable to prepare auditable accounts. On 1 October 2021, the day that it became operational, UKHSA implemented a new IT accounting system and transferred the operations of its three predecessors onto this new system. At the same time, it was responding to the COVID-19 pandemic and managing rapid large-scale changes in spending and headcount. Implementing a new IT system is always a challenge, but these circumstances brought significant additional risks and shortcomings in the quality and timeliness of financial management of the organisation. UKHSA did not have effective control over its cash management process and did not even perform bank reconciliations, one of the most basic financial controls for an organisation. It also made an operational decision to not perform stocktakes on the emergency stockpile items transferred to it; even though weaknesses in controls resulted in no effective stock counts having being undertaken on the Test and Trace inventory transferred to UKHSA or at the year end. These were just three of the many issues which meant there was a fundamental absence of financial control within the organisation, which resulted in the C&AG taking the very unusual step of disclaiming his opinion on the financial statements. Recommendation 4: UKHSA should urgently ensure robust financial controls and processes are put in place and that there is a clear plan in place to deliver unqualified accounts. Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts 7
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states UKHSA immediately established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme aimed at achieving unqualified accounts by 2024-25, acknowledging 2022-23 is not possible. A multi-year project plan for this programme will be in place by Autumn 2023, overseen by a dedicated board and Audit …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
5
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The Department has not yet developed a clear plan to remove the audit qualifications and deliver its accounts to a pre-summer recess timetable. The Department has prepared its accounts in exceptional circumstances for the past two years. It laid its 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts on 26 January 2022, five …
Read more
The Department has not yet developed a clear plan to remove the audit qualifications and deliver its accounts to a pre-summer recess timetable. The Department has prepared its accounts in exceptional circumstances for the past two years. It laid its 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts on 26 January 2022, five days ahead of the statutory deadline, and as in 2020–21, they were heavily qualified by the C&AG. For 2022–23, it plans to bring forward its laying of its Annual Report and Accounts in Parliament before the 2023 Christmas recess but there are a number of challenges in doing this. It is imperative that the Departments accounts delivery gets back on track to enable it to lay its Annual Report and Accounts ahead of the summer recess. Disappointingly, it does not yet have a credible plan to do this. The Department faces challenges from gaps in its finance function and significant problems in timely delivery in the local audit market which are required for its group accounts, which will impact on its ability to prepare more timely accounts. We have reported separately on the challenges of timeliness of local auditor reporting, which includes the audit of local NHS bodies that form part of the Departmental group. Recommendation 5: The Department must develop and implement a plan to remove the qualifications from the Departmental Group accounts and work with NHS England to restore timely financial reporting and local audit across the NHS, to support laying of the Departmental Group accounts to a pre-summer recess timetable.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government has a multi-year plan to bring forward the accounts timetable by two months annually, aiming to lay 2022-23 accounts in November 2023 and achieve a pre-summer recess timetable for 2025-26. It acknowledges challenges with local audit capacity, which are being addressed.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
6
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
There have been repeated and unacceptable governance and accounting failures within the Departmental Group which has led to poor financial control, undermined Parliamentary accountability, and money being spent without Parliamentary approval. The Department has failed to implement adequate financial control across the Group which has resulted in numerous qualifications of …
Read more
There have been repeated and unacceptable governance and accounting failures within the Departmental Group which has led to poor financial control, undermined Parliamentary accountability, and money being spent without Parliamentary approval. The Department has failed to implement adequate financial control across the Group which has resulted in numerous qualifications of both ‘true and fair’ and ‘regularity’ opinions. The Department’s own Core and/ or Group accounts have had multiple qualifications over the last three years. The UKHSA accounts were disclaimed in 2021–22, the year it was established. NHS Property Services accounts were qualified in 2021–22, NHS England had regularity qualifications in 2020–21 and in 2021–22, and issues within University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust resulted in a disclaimer in 2019–20 and a delayed adverse opinion in 2020–21. Recommendation 6: The Department must set out how it will establish sufficient capability to deliver effective oversight across its Group to manage emerging and developing issues and ensure it avoids future financial and governance failings. 8 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts 1 Inventory procurement in response to COVID-19
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it has already established a 'financial reset programme' which implemented robust financial controls and governance across its group. While acknowledging challenges in ensuring full compliance, it maintains that these processes and controls are proportionate risk mitigation and are kept under continual review.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
1
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
On the basis of a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG), we took evidence from the Department of Health and Social Care (the Department) and the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) on the Department’s Annual Report and Accounts for 2021–22.1
Read more
On the basis of a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General (C&AG), we took evidence from the Department of Health and Social Care (the Department) and the UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) on the Department’s Annual Report and Accounts for 2021–22.1
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it regularly updates the Committee on PPE inventory controls, disposal, and commercial resolution through quarterly updates and a March 2023 strategy document. It details how SCCL manages the PPE supply chain, inventory controls, and disposal, and how the Contract Dissolution Team works …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
7
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The Department continues to review the PPE contracts it entered into to identify suppliers that did not deliver against their contractual terms. By February 2022, the Department had negotiated the cancellation or variation of contracts to reduce the original supply of PPE by 1.21 billion items with an associated reduction …
Read more
The Department continues to review the PPE contracts it entered into to identify suppliers that did not deliver against their contractual terms. By February 2022, the Department had negotiated the cancellation or variation of contracts to reduce the original supply of PPE by 1.21 billion items with an associated reduction in value of £572 million.15 There have been 60 contracts identified by the Department where there was dissatisfaction due to required standards, quality control or due to contractual breach. The value of these contracts is £1.77 billion. In addition, there were twelve contracts held by the Department’s subsidiary Supply Chain Coordination Ltd which were in dispute as at 31 December 2022, where suppliers were under investigation as they were in breach of their obligations.16 The Department confirmed that on resolution of the disputes the appropriate information will be released to the public.17 Stockpiling for a future emergency
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it is already providing regular quarterly updates on PPE inventory, disposals, and contract resolution activities, with SCCL managing the PPE supply chain and excess stock disposal, and the Contract Dissolution Team continuing to recover value from defaulting suppliers.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
8
Recommendation
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
As well as the significant volumes of PPE it purchased, and is now disposing of, the Department entered into contracts for both COVID-19 vaccines and COVID-19 medicines which commit it to procure future stock. It recognised impairments on these contracts in 2021–22 of £1.7 billion for COVID-19 vaccines and £1.8 …
Read more
As well as the significant volumes of PPE it purchased, and is now disposing of, the Department entered into contracts for both COVID-19 vaccines and COVID-19 medicines which commit it to procure future stock. It recognised impairments on these contracts in 2021–22 of £1.7 billion for COVID-19 vaccines and £1.8 billion for COVID-19 8 Letter from DHSC to PAC, dated 16 March 2023 9 Q 84 10 Letter from DHSC to PAC, dated 16 March 2023 11 Qq 96, 100 12 Qq 98, 99 13 C&AG’s Report, para 5 14 Q 90 15 DHSC 2021–22 ARA, page 57 16 Letter from DHSC to PAC, dated 16 March 2023 17 Q 107 10 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts medicines with a limited shelf life which it now does not expect to use.18 We questioned the Department on why the impairments of COVID-19 vaccines and medicines were required and it confirmed that medicines were purchased as an ‘insurance policy’ at the beginning of the Omicron wave as there were concerns that it would be a vaccine-escaping variant and this would be protection for the most vulnerable. The Department however continued to explain that it would not expect to have such impairments in the future as there is no expectation that it would have to sign ‘onerous’ contracts again.19
Show less
Government response AI summary
The department recognizes the need to manage future procurement commitments to ensure value for money and minimize potential losses, and is working to improve forecasting and demand planning, and to manage contract flexibilities to reduce future stock commitments where possible.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
9
Recommendation
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
In our June 2022 report on the Department’s 2020–21 Annual Report and Accounts we noted the lack of planning for how big a PPE stockpile needed to be, and also the need to build greater resilience into the supply chain.20 We asked the Department again about the need and its …
Read more
In our June 2022 report on the Department’s 2020–21 Annual Report and Accounts we noted the lack of planning for how big a PPE stockpile needed to be, and also the need to build greater resilience into the supply chain.20 We asked the Department again about the need and its future plans for stockpiling items that may be required in the event of a future pandemic. The Department stated there are a number of decisions yet to be made regarding what is included in a stockpile for future pandemics.21 It said that the stockpile held was invaluable for the first few months of the COVID-19 pandemic.22 However, one of its big limitations was the ability to create domestic supply and it advised us that it is working on strengthening domestic PPE supply chains.23 The Department confirmed that, at the time we took evidence in March, it had at least four months’ worth of PPE, particularly inventory, in its stockpiles.24 18 DHSC 2021–22 ARA, page 364 19 Q 82 20 Committee of Public Accounts, Department of Health and Social Care 2020–21 Annual Report and Accounts, Sixth Report of Session 2022–23, HC 253, 10 June 2022 21 Q 101 22 Q 117 23 Q 117 24 Q 80 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts 11 2 UKHSA
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and details a range of specific actions for building resilience, including a clinical countermeasure programme, a UK-Moderna partnership for vaccine manufacturing, and ongoing work with SCCL on PPE volumes, long-term resilience, and stock rotation.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
10
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Not Addressed
On 18 August 2020, the Department announced a reorganisation of public health in England. The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) was subsequently established as an Executive Agency of the Department on 1 April 2021 with its Chair and Chief Executive appointed on the same day. It became fully operational on …
Read more
On 18 August 2020, the Department announced a reorganisation of public health in England. The UK Health Security Agency (UKHSA) was subsequently established as an Executive Agency of the Department on 1 April 2021 with its Chair and Chief Executive appointed on the same day. It became fully operational on 1 October 2021, when it became responsible for the health protection functions of the former Public Health England (‘PHE’) and became responsible for NHS Test and Trace and the Joint Biosecurity Centre, both of which had previously been divisions of the Department.25 Establishment of UKHSA
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government's response outlines UKHSA's governance improvements, but this conclusion was a factual observation about the agency's establishment, not a recommendation requiring action.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
11
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Not Addressed
The Department told us that there was an operational imperative to establish UKHSA before the winter of 2021–22, which was driven by the state of the pandemic and the need to create a single source of advice for Ministers and a single operational response.26 The establishment of UKHSA was a …
Read more
The Department told us that there was an operational imperative to establish UKHSA before the winter of 2021–22, which was driven by the state of the pandemic and the need to create a single source of advice for Ministers and a single operational response.26 The establishment of UKHSA was a complex task. The Chair of UKHSA compared it to creating a FTSE 50 sized company through a merger of three entities, with different systems and cultures, in six months.27
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government's response details governance improvements at UKHSA but does not directly engage with the conclusion's observations regarding the operational imperative for its rapid establishment or the inherent complexity of the task.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
12
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Not Addressed
The complexity was compounded by the changing remit for UKHSA and by policy decisions which had significant implications for UKHSA’s size and structure. For example, in March 2022 with the implementation of the ‘living with covid’ strategy, UKHSA began a restructure which resulted in it decreasing its workforce from 18,000 …
Read more
The complexity was compounded by the changing remit for UKHSA and by policy decisions which had significant implications for UKHSA’s size and structure. For example, in March 2022 with the implementation of the ‘living with covid’ strategy, UKHSA began a restructure which resulted in it decreasing its workforce from 18,000 to 6,700 full-time equivalents.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government's response focuses on UKHSA's corporate governance and oversight, rather than directly addressing the observed complexities stemming from its changing remit and restructuring outlined in this conclusion.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
13
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
On 1 October 2021, UKHSA had a Chief Executive and a non-executive Chair, both of whom had been appointed on 1 April 2021. UKHSA told us that the Chief Executive, despite her expertise in the science of public health, did not have experience in the other elements of running a …
Read more
On 1 October 2021, UKHSA had a Chief Executive and a non-executive Chair, both of whom had been appointed on 1 April 2021. UKHSA told us that the Chief Executive, despite her expertise in the science of public health, did not have experience in the other elements of running a complex organisation. The Chair of UKHSA therefore saw his role during the first 12 months as providing the Chief Executive with support in some of the functions where she had less experience, such as technology operations and procurement. This resulted in his role departing from the traditional Chair’s role of challenging and scrutinising management to taking more of an executive role.28
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states the implicit recommendation is implemented, detailing how UKHSA established full corporate governance by September 2022, completed non-executive recruitment, and engaged GIAA for a governance review, with identified actions completed by March 2023 to ensure traditional roles and strong oversight.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
14
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
No additional non-executive directors were appointed until after the 2021–22 financial year. As a result, UKHSA did not comply with the principles of HM Treasury and the Cabinet Office’s Corporate governance in central government departments: code of good practice and UKHSA’s Head of Internal Audit concluded that, in their opinion, …
Read more
No additional non-executive directors were appointed until after the 2021–22 financial year. As a result, UKHSA did not comply with the principles of HM Treasury and the Cabinet Office’s Corporate governance in central government departments: code of good practice and UKHSA’s Head of Internal Audit concluded that, in their opinion, UKHSA’s corporate governance arrangements were unsatisfactory.29 The Department acknowledged that this was not normal and that in more ordinary circumstances it would have tried to establish a new entity at the beginning of the financial year with all necessary governance arrangements in place. In the Department’s view, the circumstances of mid- 2021 meant this was not possible.30 25 Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, UK Health Security Agency Annual Report and Accounts 2021/22, HC 1086, 26 January 2023, p. 91. 26 Qq 14, 27 27 Q 17 28 Q 50 29 C&AG’s Report on UKHSA, p. 92. 30 Q 14 12 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states UKHSA has established a full suite of corporate governance arrangements, including completing non-executive recruitment by April 2022 and establishing committees by September 2022, with a GIAA review identifying improvements completed by March 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
15
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
We asked the Department whether, given the risks associated with the establishment of UKHSA, it had considered an alternative timing for establishing the new organisation to ensure that an appropriate governance framework could have been put in place. The Department said that its priority was ensuring that it had the …
Read more
We asked the Department whether, given the risks associated with the establishment of UKHSA, it had considered an alternative timing for establishing the new organisation to ensure that an appropriate governance framework could have been put in place. The Department said that its priority was ensuring that it had the most effective system in place for managing the pandemic during the winter of 2021–22.31
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states UKHSA has established a full suite of corporate governance arrangements, including completing non-executive recruitment and establishing committees by September 2022, with a GIAA review identifying improvements completed by March 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
16
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The absence of governance arrangements at UKHSA, during a time of significant change and operational challenge, meant that there was inadequate scrutiny and oversight over UKHSA. We asked the Department what it had done to support UKHSA to help mitigate the risks associated with the absence of governance arrangements. The …
Read more
The absence of governance arrangements at UKHSA, during a time of significant change and operational challenge, meant that there was inadequate scrutiny and oversight over UKHSA. We asked the Department what it had done to support UKHSA to help mitigate the risks associated with the absence of governance arrangements. The Department said that it has done this in a very light-tough way.32 When we asked for detail on this light touch involvement, the Department said that its own Audit and Risk Committee had discussions on two occasions about the risks facing UKHSA in its establishment.33 Financial management and control
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states that UKHSA has already implemented a full suite of corporate governance arrangements, including completing non-executive recruitment, establishing committees by September 2022, and completing a GIAA review with actions by March 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
17
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The C&AG’s audit of UKHSA’s first set of accounts resulted in him disclaiming his opinions.34 This means that he was unable to give an opinion on whether the accounts were ‘true and fair’ or on whether the transactions recorded in the accounts were applied to the purposes intended by Parliament …
Read more
The C&AG’s audit of UKHSA’s first set of accounts resulted in him disclaiming his opinions.34 This means that he was unable to give an opinion on whether the accounts were ‘true and fair’ or on whether the transactions recorded in the accounts were applied to the purposes intended by Parliament (‘regularity’).
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a fully clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan due by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
18
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The UKHSA accounts were ‘disclaimed’ as: the inventory transferred from Public Health England (£254 million) and the Department (£794 million) to UKHSA on 1 October 2021 was not subject to stock counts, £3.3 billion of consumption of Test and Trace inventory was not supported by records and the inventory held …
Read more
The UKHSA accounts were ‘disclaimed’ as: the inventory transferred from Public Health England (£254 million) and the Department (£794 million) to UKHSA on 1 October 2021 was not subject to stock counts, £3.3 billion of consumption of Test and Trace inventory was not supported by records and the inventory held as at 31 March 2022 was not subject to stock counts until several months after the year end; UKHSA was unable to provide sufficient evidence to support the £1.9 billion accruals balance as at 31 March 2022 and £3.0 billion expenditure on the purchase of goods and services during 2021–22; and UKHSA was unable to provide sufficient evidence to support journal adjustments made to the accounts.35
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a fully clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan due by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
19
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
It is very unusual for an auditor to disclaim their opinion. No C&AG has disclaimed an audit opinion since January 2006, concerning the Home Office resource accounts 2004–05.36 UKHSA confirmed that they do not anticipate being able to produce accounts which will be unqualified until 2023–24 at the earliest.37
Read more
It is very unusual for an auditor to disclaim their opinion. No C&AG has disclaimed an audit opinion since January 2006, concerning the Home Office resource accounts 2004–05.36 UKHSA confirmed that they do not anticipate being able to produce accounts which will be unqualified until 2023–24 at the earliest.37
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a fully clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan due by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
20
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
There were multiple root causes of UKHSA’s inability to produce auditable accounts. One of the key causes was the accounting system that UKHSA implemented on 1 October
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the observation and states that UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, with the aim of achieving a clean audit opinion for the 2024-25 accounts and a multi-year project plan in place by …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
21
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
We asked UKHSA whether it would have been better to use one of the systems used by its predecessor entities rather than implementing the new system on the day it became operational. UKHSA said that it had inherited the decision to implement the new system from Public Health England and …
Read more
We asked UKHSA whether it would have been better to use one of the systems used by its predecessor entities rather than implementing the new system on the day it became operational. UKHSA said that it had inherited the decision to implement the new system from Public Health England and acknowledged that, in hindsight, it may have been preferable to run existing systems side by side.40
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan in place by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
22
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
UKHSA also experienced significant difficulties with staffing which compromised its ability to provide evidence and explanations to support the figures reflected in the accounts. The C&AG reported that one barrier to his ability to obtain evidence to allow him to give an audit opinion was the transitory nature of UKHSA’s …
Read more
UKHSA also experienced significant difficulties with staffing which compromised its ability to provide evidence and explanations to support the figures reflected in the accounts. The C&AG reported that one barrier to his ability to obtain evidence to allow him to give an audit opinion was the transitory nature of UKHSA’s workforce. This meant that officials who had prepared figures for the financial statements had left the organisation by the time of the audit and were not able to provide explanations and evidence to support those figures.41 During our evidence session, UKHSA echoed this, noting that from April to August 2022 it reduced its headcount by almost two thirds resulting in a loss of continuity of knowledge to help address the NAO’s audit queries.42 UKHSA also stated that two of the predecessor entities to UKHSA, NHS Test and Trace and the Joint Biosecurity Centre, did not have a history of budget and accounting discipline which further contributed to the difficulties in providing evidence and explanations.43
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan in place by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
23
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
There were also operational decisions which UKHSA and the Department took which meant that some form of accounts qualification was always likely. The Department decided not to count the stockpile of emergency goods transferred from Public Health England to the UK Health Security Agency on 1 October 2022. The Department’s …
Read more
There were also operational decisions which UKHSA and the Department took which meant that some form of accounts qualification was always likely. The Department decided not to count the stockpile of emergency goods transferred from Public Health England to the UK Health Security Agency on 1 October 2022. The Department’s view was that counting these stocks on the date of transfer would have compromised the autumn 2021 vaccine roll-out because it would have required the closure of warehouses.44 However, there were other inventories transferred to UKHSA, for example the NHS Test and Trace inventories transferred from the Department, where no stock counts were performed because the Department’s inventory management systems were not adequate.45 38 C&AG’s Report on UKHSA, p. 94. 39 C&AG’s Report on UKHSA, p. 94. 40 Q 21 41 C&AG’s Report on UKHSA, p. 93. 42 Q 22 43 Q 17 44 Qq 38, 51 45 C&AG’s Report on UKHSA, p. 94. 14 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts 3 Departmental group oversight Timely publication of the Annual Report and Accounts
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan in place by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
24
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
To ensure timely accountability for the spending of public funds, Treasury set an administrative deadline of 30 June after the end of the financial year for Departments to publish their Annual Report and Accounts, and no later than parliamentary summer recess in July. The Department has a statutory deadline of …
Read more
To ensure timely accountability for the spending of public funds, Treasury set an administrative deadline of 30 June after the end of the financial year for Departments to publish their Annual Report and Accounts, and no later than parliamentary summer recess in July. The Department has a statutory deadline of 31 January to publish its annual report and accounts.46 The Department laid its 2020–21 Annual Report and Accounts on the statutory deadline of 31 January 2022, and it acknowledged that this was a “incredibly challenging year to produce the Annual Report and Accounts”47. The Department told us in a previous session held on 07 March 2022 that it was working hard to bring the publication of its 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts forward, with an aim to publish these in November 2022.48 The 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts were however laid on 26 January 2023, only five days earlier than the prior year.
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and commits to a multi-year plan to return to a pre-summer recess timetable for laying accounts by the 2025-26 financial year, aiming to publish the 2022-23 accounts in November 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
25
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
We asked the Department about the timing of the 2022–23 annual report and accounts, the Department confirmed that it was aiming to lay its Accounts before the 2023 Christmas recess and then to gradually improve the timeliness in future years.49 The Department is currently working on a multi-year plan to …
Read more
We asked the Department about the timing of the 2022–23 annual report and accounts, the Department confirmed that it was aiming to lay its Accounts before the 2023 Christmas recess and then to gradually improve the timeliness in future years.49 The Department is currently working on a multi-year plan to enable the Annual Report and Accounts to be laid pre summer recess in line with Treasurys expectation, with its aim being to bring forward the laying date by a couple of months each year.50
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and commits to a multi-year plan to return to a pre-summer recess timetable for laying accounts by the 2025-26 financial year, aiming to publish the 2022-23 accounts in November 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
26
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The Department faces two main challenges to bring the audit timetable forward, issues within the Department’s control and issues within the local audit market. The Department acknowledges that it is always looking to build its finance capability and identified three areas where more expertise is needed: financial, commercial and digital. …
Read more
The Department faces two main challenges to bring the audit timetable forward, issues within the Department’s control and issues within the local audit market. The Department acknowledges that it is always looking to build its finance capability and identified three areas where more expertise is needed: financial, commercial and digital. The Department however confirmed it had enough people within the finance team but that its focus was on the financial expertise of non-finance staff.51 There are expected issues in 2022–23 with the introduction of a new accounting standard, IFRS 16, which fundamentally changes the way entities account for leases.52 The written evidence submitted by the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales (ICAEW) also raises concern with regards to the staffing levels within the finance function.53
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and commits to a multi-year plan to return to a pre-summer recess timetable for laying accounts by the 2025-26 financial year, aiming to publish the 2022-23 accounts in November 2023, while acknowledging external factors like local audit capacity.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
27
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
We questioned the Department on the capacity of other bodies in its Group to prepare their Accounts to the required timescales, as we were aware that a number of bodies did not yet have auditors appointed for 2022–23, and this could have a significant impact on the Department being able …
Read more
We questioned the Department on the capacity of other bodies in its Group to prepare their Accounts to the required timescales, as we were aware that a number of bodies did not yet have auditors appointed for 2022–23, and this could have a significant impact on the Department being able to bring the laying date of the Group Annual Report and Accounts forward. The Department confirmed that there will be significantly more accounts preparation and audit issues in 2022–23 as Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) were formed mid-year meaning there are audits to be undertaken of both ICBs and also the 46 HM Treasury ‘Dear Accounting Officer Letter’, DAO 08/21, 16 December 2021 47 Department of Health and Social Care Annual Report and Accounts 2020–21,HC 1053, 31 January 2022, page 2 48 Committee of Public Accounts, Department of Health and Social Care 2020–21 Annual Report and Accounts, Sixth Report of Session 2022–23, HC 253, 10 June 2022, para 31 49 Q 3 50 Q 4 51 Qq 140–142 52 Q 6 53 Q 138 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts 15 former Clinical Commissioning Groups that ICBs replaced. The Department said it was working with the Department for Levelling Up Homes and Communities (DLUHC) to remove barriers to entry for more audit firms to enter the local audit market.54 Financial control across the departmental group
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and commits to a multi-year plan to return to a pre-summer recess timetable for laying accounts by the 2025-26 financial year, aiming to publish the 2022-23 accounts in November 2023, and states it is working to address external factors like local audit …
Read full response →
HM Treasury
28
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The Department and bodies within its Group have had a number of financial governance and accounting failures in recent years. The Department Core and Group accounts have been qualified by the C&AG for the past two years. In both 2020–21 and 2021–22 there was a ‘true and fair’ qualification arising …
Read more
The Department and bodies within its Group have had a number of financial governance and accounting failures in recent years. The Department Core and Group accounts have been qualified by the C&AG for the past two years. In both 2020–21 and 2021–22 there was a ‘true and fair’ qualification arising in respect of inventory, this arose as the Department was unable to perform stock takes to evidence the existence, completeness and valuation of inventory.55 The Department acknowledged that the inventory qualification will remain until the Department has disposed of all of the excess and unusable PPE it has.56
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it has already undertaken a financial reset programme to establish robust financial controls and governance, putting in place proportionate controls to reduce future financial and governance failings, with a target implementation date of December 2023 for the programme.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
29
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The C&AG also qualified the Groups ‘other accruals’ in 2020–21 as there was insufficient assurance in respect of existence and valuation of £17.3 billion, the Department accrues expenditure it has incurred but has not yet been invoiced for and therefore a liability which will need to be paid in future. …
Read more
The C&AG also qualified the Groups ‘other accruals’ in 2020–21 as there was insufficient assurance in respect of existence and valuation of £17.3 billion, the Department accrues expenditure it has incurred but has not yet been invoiced for and therefore a liability which will need to be paid in future. In 2019–20 the C&AG qualified his ‘true and fair’ opinion on the Core Departments ‘other financial assets’ due to a disagreement in the application of financial reporting standard IFRS 9. The Department did not impair the value of the loans to NHS Trusts and Foundation Trusts, resulting in assets being overstated by an estimated £2.2 billion.57
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government states it has already undertaken a financial reset programme to establish robust financial controls and governance across the department and its arm’s length bodies, which has put in place proportionate controls to reduce future financial and governance failings.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
30
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
Furthermore, the C&AG has qualified his ‘regularity’ opinion on the DHSC Group accounts for the past two years: the Department exceeded its budgetary limit for Resource Non-Budget Expenditure as authorised by Parliament in 2021–22 as a budget of £nil was authorised and the Department incurred an outturn of £2.457 billion; …
Read more
Furthermore, the C&AG has qualified his ‘regularity’ opinion on the DHSC Group accounts for the past two years: the Department exceeded its budgetary limit for Resource Non-Budget Expenditure as authorised by Parliament in 2021–22 as a budget of £nil was authorised and the Department incurred an outturn of £2.457 billion; and in 2020–21, the Department spent £1.3 billion on projects they were required to but did not have the appropriate approval from Treasury for, and therefore was irregular, and also in 2020– 21 there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that the expenditure incurred by the Department, particularly on COVID-19 was regular, with the assessment of potential fraud losses being inadequate.58
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the implied concern, stating it has already implemented a financial reset programme with robust controls to reduce future financial and governance failings, which are kept under continual review.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
31
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
The C&AG being unable to provide an opinion on the UKHSA 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts59 (see above) resulted in further ‘true and fair’ and ‘regularity’ qualifications on the Departmental Group accounts.60 . We questioned the Department on when it realised that the difficulties inherited by UKHSA would impact on …
Read more
The C&AG being unable to provide an opinion on the UKHSA 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts59 (see above) resulted in further ‘true and fair’ and ‘regularity’ qualifications on the Departmental Group accounts.60 . We questioned the Department on when it realised that the difficulties inherited by UKHSA would impact on the Group accounts. The Department said that ‘the precise issues’ and the amount of evidence not available to support the audit only became apparent to it in late 2022 and in January 2023, and that it was the NAO’s audit which had revealed these scale of these issues.61 54 Q 6 55 DHSC 2021–22 ARA, page 252 56 Qq 79, 90 57 DHSC 2021–22 ARA, page 253 58 DHSC 2020–21 ARA, p. 192 59 UKHSA ARA 2021–22 pages 86–87 60 DHSC 2021–22 ARA, pages 252–256 61 Q 36 16 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and states UKHSA has established a Finance and Control Improvement Programme to strengthen financial controls and processes, aiming for a fully clean audit opinion by 2024-25, with a multi-year project plan due by Autumn 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
32
Conclusion
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
There have been other qualifications across the Departmental Group. The NHS Property Services (NHSPS) accounts were qualified in 2021–22 as NHSPS were unable to demonstrate compliance with the Financial Reporting Framework and account for the expenditure, assets and liabilities arising from certain contracts in accordance with IFRS16 Leases. There were …
Read more
There have been other qualifications across the Departmental Group. The NHS Property Services (NHSPS) accounts were qualified in 2021–22 as NHSPS were unable to demonstrate compliance with the Financial Reporting Framework and account for the expenditure, assets and liabilities arising from certain contracts in accordance with IFRS16 Leases. There were 182 rental arrangements with approximate annual payments of £7.7 million, and NHSPS was unable to provide documentation to determine the substance of arrangements.62 The NHS England 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts ‘regularity’ opinion was qualified by the C&AG as ineligible payments were made to suspended medical practitioners; two suspended medical practitioners received suspension payments, over a number of years, with a combined total of £1 million to which they were not entitled.63 In addition, the C&AG qualified his ‘regularity’ opinion on the NHS England 2020–21 Annual Report and Accounts, also as NHS England failed to comply with Managing Public Money and made payment without Treasury approval for a special severance payment.64
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees with the implied concern, stating it has already implemented a financial reset programme with robust controls to reduce future failings, which are kept under continual review.
Read full response →
HM Treasury
33
Recommendation
Sixty-Second Report - Department of Hea…
Accepted
At the time of our evidence session, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust (UHL) had yet to publish its 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts. UHL’s auditor was not able to obtain sufficient, appropriate evidence upon which to form an opinion for 2019–20, and issued an adverse audit opinion for 2020–21, …
Read more
At the time of our evidence session, University Hospitals of Leicester NHS Trust (UHL) had yet to publish its 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts. UHL’s auditor was not able to obtain sufficient, appropriate evidence upon which to form an opinion for 2019–20, and issued an adverse audit opinion for 2020–21, due to system and control weaknesses resulting in material misstatements.65 We asked the Department what oversight it had of other hospitals which may be having similar issues to UHL. The Department advised us that the NHS has a financial oversight framework that looks at financial and performance measures. The Department also advised that it has regular meetings with the NHS, at which it had not been alerted to similar concerns about any other specific trusts.66 62 NHS Property Services Limited, NHS Property Services Limited Annual Report and Accounts 2021/22, 17 February 2023 63 NHS Commissioning Board, NHS Commissioning Board Annual Report and Accounts 2021–22, HC 1011, 30 January 2023 64 NHS Commissioning Board, NHS Commissioning Board Annual Report and Accounts 2020–21, HC 1027, 3 February 2022 65 C&AG‘s Report, para 17 66 Qq 136–137 Department of Health and Social Care 2021–22 Annual Report and Accounts 17
Show less
Government response AI summary
The government agrees and details its financial reset programme, which has established robust financial controls and a risk-based framework across its bodies to reduce future financial and governance failings, with a target implementation date of December 2023.
Read full response →
HM Treasury