Recommendation 12

We have serious concerns about the compatibility of the conditional immunity scheme with the Convention. However, if the immunity scheme is to remain in the Bill, there should be a higher threshold test for the granting of immunity. At a minimum, the panel must be required to test the veracity of the account given by seeking evidence from relevant third parties, including victims and their 38 Legislative Scrutiny: Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Bill families where relevant (see Annex, Amendment 9). Additionally, immunity from prosecution should be revocable in circumstances where a false account has been given (see Annex, Amendment 10).