Source · Select Committees · Human Rights (Joint Committee)
Recommendation 87
87
Accepted
With regard to children, Open Rights Group notes that collecting biometric data from children over...
Conclusion
With regard to children, Open Rights Group notes that collecting biometric data from children over 16 without consent could violate child protection standards: “According to the guidance of the Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) on processing sensitive personal data under the UK GDPR, biometric data is categorised as special category data and requires explicit consent. The guidance stresses that when dealing with minors’ data, additional safeguards must be implemented to protect their rights. Therefore, collecting biometric data from children over 16 without proper consent could breach child protection standards, as it fails to meet the stringent consent requirements and the enhanced safeguards necessary for processing such sensitive information.”
Government Response Summary
The government noted the concern regarding biometric data collection from children over 16 without consent, stating that the Bill aligns with wider biometrics policy which requires a responsible adult for those under 16, implying no new action is needed for those over 16.
Government Response
Accepted
HM Government
Accepted
We thank the Committee for its consideration of Clause 35 and note the concern about the transfer of personal data. The Bill does not provide a broad-brush approach or disapplication of data protection safeguards. Instead, it simply provides that for the purpose of international transfers, such processing is taken to be necessary for important reasons of public interest, meaning a derogation will be engaged. The processing will still need to comply with the general principles (Article 5 UK GDPR), lawful basis (Article 6 UK GDPR), which will generally require that processing is necessary for the performance of a task in the public interest and, in respect of any special category data, that the processing is necessary for reasons of substantial public interest (Article 9 UK GDPR). In this case, the public interest is that such processing may be used to support decisions relating to immigration permission after a person has been evacuated or had their exit facilitated from a third state. The Home Office will ensure that due diligence is paid when sharing any personal data, to ensure it is appropriately safeguarded, with particular attention paid to which third parties and countries the data is shared with. We also note paragraph 87, which identifies the importance of consent for collection of biometrics of children over 16. The Bill is aligned with wider biometrics policy applicable to anyone applying to come to the UK. The presence of a responsible adult is required for the collection of biometric data from children under 16 years old, a position that reflects existing legislation relating to the provision of biometrics under the Immigration Acts and for nationality purposes and the increased rights and responsibilities granted to those aged over 16 years.