Select committee: Economic Affairs Committee
Conclusion 39
2nd Report - Universal Credit isn't working: proposals for reform
Published 31 Jul 2020
Paragraph 202
Economic Affairs Committee The economics of Universal Credit All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Conclusion (the committee's words)
Conditionality must be adapted so that it is able to accommodate dynamically changing labour market conditions, including at the local level . The DWP should, with HM Treasury, the Department for Business , Energy and Industrial Strategy and other relevant departments, review how conditionality should be reconstructed to support millions of people back into work in an environment in which there are far fewer vacancies and in which large sectors of the economy such as non-food retail, hospitality and tourism—which are most likely to employ young people—remain depressed or do not recover fully. The DWP should ramp up and improve the provision of training that is available to claimants .
From: Economic Affairs Committee, 2nd Report - Universal Credit isn't working: proposals for reform, paragraph 202, 31 July 2020
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 13 October 2020 (deadline 30 September 2020).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The Government 'notes' the Committee's recommendations and says it is 'surprised by several of the Committee's observations', and in the areas covered below it does not take forward the main design changes proposed.
- On payment design, the Department says it "will not be taking this recommendation forward" on a three-month fixed award, and "will not be introducing this choice by default" of monthly or twice-monthly payment. It cites accuracy risks and preparation for monthly paid work.
- The Department states that "in 2021 we will be increasing the time over which an advance can be repaid to from 12 to 24 months". It "rejects" the proposed non-repayable two-week initial grant, citing fraud risk.
- The Department "does not accept" the recommendations on the two-child limit and on reducing the taper rate. It says it "keeps the taper rate under review".
- It "intend[s] to keep childcare support integrated as part of UC" and "does not publish estimates of UC take-up rates". On the benefit cap, it "acknowledges" the recommendation and says the statutory review "will happen at an appropriate time".