Select committee: Economic Affairs Committee

Taxing corporations in a global economy: is a new approach needed?

Closed Opened 27 Mar 2013 Closed 30 Oct 2013
Inquiry scope (the committee's words)
Call for evidence Recent high profile cases involving multinational firms have raised the profile of the level of tax paid by large corporations and it has been suggested that for large firms corporation tax is becoming now a voluntary arrangement. Is there a good rationale for the existing system of taxing corporate profits? Who bears the burden of corporation tax? What proportion of total tax receipts should come from corporation tax? How vulnerable are UK corporation tax revenues to recession or tax avoidance? How does corporation tax affect decisions by firms on where to locate, how much to invest and where to declare profits? Should the taxation of SME’s be reformed? Do schemes such as Enterprise Investment Scheme leverage extra investment in the UK and do they represent good value for money? Is there a need to reform the basis of the international allocation of multinational profits between countries? Should this be based on existing conventions as suggested by the OECD or is there a need for more fundamental reform? Is there a meaningful distinction between ‘harmful’ and ‘fair’ tax competition? How successful is HMRC in dealing with large international business? Has the use of aggressive tax avoidance schemes increased or decreased over the last decade? Should the promoters of aggressive tax avoidance schemes be named and shamed? Is there a need for greater transparency by multinational companies in declaring tax paid in different countries?

Where it stands

The inquiry is closed, opened 27 March 2013.

The committee has published 2 reports, most recently 1st Report: Tackling corporate tax avoidance in a global economy: is a new approach needed? on 31 July 2013.

The government's response to each report

1st Report: Tackling corporate tax avoidance in a global economy: is a new approach needed?

Published 14 October 2013.

Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.

The Government notes the Committee's recommendations for a new Treasury review of corporation tax but considers such a review "of limited value" given its existing work, which it says centres on competitiveness, tackling avoidance and reform of the international framework through the OECD.

  • It agrees that the current international system needs reform and says the UK is "fully supportive of and closely engaged with" the OECD BEPS project, to which it says the UK has contributed a further €400,000.
  • It disagrees with a separate Treasury review of interest relief and debt, saying the work forms part of the OECD BEPS Project. On an allowance for corporate equity, it says it "is reviewing the wider case" following the Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards.
  • It agrees with promoting the G8 information-sharing proposals but disagrees with public disclosure of tax returns, saying this would put the UK "at a competitive disadvantage" and "do nothing to aid our efforts to tackle tax avoidance".
  • It disagrees with penalties under the GAAR "at this stage", citing a need for a "bedding-in period", but says it "has not ruled out future action" to attach penalties "if necessary".

Read the government's response ↗ Report an error

Recommendations and conclusions 0 shown

No recommendations or conclusions are indexed for this inquiry yet.

Reports

2 reports