Select committee: Constitution Committee
Conclusion 24
9th Report - The roles of the Lord Chancellor and the Law Officers
Published 18 Jan 2023
Paragraph 207
Constitution Committee Role of the Lord Chancellor and the Law Officers All items in this report Report on parliament.uk ↗ Inquiry on parliament.uk ↗
Conclusion (the committee's words)
The Lord Chancellor’s limited role in judicial appointments has been settled since the enactment of the CRA in 2005. The current system enables political oversight of the process through the Lord Chancellor’s ability to reject or request reconsideration of the candidate recommended to them. In our 2012 report Judicial Appointments we cautioned against the over-politicisation of the process. Nonetheless, since then arguments have been made for more accountability and transparency in the process. Any change to the current system would need very carefully to balance political accountability with the essential need to avoid political interference with judicial independence.
From: Constitution Committee, 9th Report - The roles of the Lord Chancellor and the Law Officers, paragraph 207, 18 January 2023
Government response
The government responded to the whole report on 17 March 2023 (deadline 18 March 2023).
Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.The Government agrees with the Committee on the importance of the rule of law and the value of Law Officers being politicians, but it has "no current plans to review the existing arrangements" for the offices of Lord Chancellor and the Law Officers.
- The Government agrees that "defending the judiciary against unfair, personal or threatening abuse is a core part of the Lord Chancellor’s role", but "respectfully disagrees" that a Lord Chancellor must intervene publicly, saying that an expectation of public intervention "might prove counterproductive".
- On a constitutional lead, the Government believes there is "greater strength in having a number of senior Ministerial leads on discrete constitutional matters", rather than the Lord Chancellor holding overall responsibility, and says ministerial appointments are a matter for the Prime Minister.
- On the Ministerial Code and Cabinet Manual, the Government is "always open to looking at whether updates or amendments are needed" and "remains committed to producing an updated edition of the Cabinet Manual before the end of the current Parliament". It notes a possible danger that codification "is reductive".
- On the Lord Chancellor's oath, the Government "remains unpersuaded" that rewording it to refer to upholding the rule of law would affect the discharge of the duty. On the Internal Market Act and Northern Ireland Protocol Bill, the Law Officers "have nothing further to add at this time".