Source · Select Committees · Justice Committee
Recommendation 9
9
Deferred
Paragraph: 50
Ensure statutory duty to publish sentencing information in individual courts is fulfilled.
Conclusion
Data on sentencing in individual courts will help the public to understand sentencing trends in their local area and is likely to help to stimulate local media interest and reporting. The Sentencing Council and the Ministry of Justice should work together to ensure that the statutory duty to publish information on sentencing in individual courts is fulfilled. We would ask that the Ministry of Justice and the Sentencing Council provide an update on what progress has been made on fulfilling this duty six months after the publication of this report.
Government Response Summary
The government's response deflects the recommendation about fulfilling the statutory duty to publish sentencing data in individual courts by instead detailing the existing practice of broadcasting judges' sentencing remarks in Crown Courts and live-streaming cases from the Court of Appeal, aimed at public education.
Paragraph Reference:
50
Government Response
Deferred
HM Government
Deferred
9. Public education: Since July 2022, television cameras have been allowed into Crown Courts for the first time to broadcast judges’ sentencing remarks. Allowing broadcasting in this way is intended to help the public better understand how our justice system works and see justice being delivered to build trust and confidence in the system. The public can access the Sky News (Courts) YouTube channel where all previous broadcast sentencing remarks are available to view. We have recently expanded the range of judiciary who can be filmed, to include Court of Appeal judges sitting in the Crown Court, who sometimes preside over the most high-profile and serious cases. However, not all sentencing remarks are filmed as applications to film are made by approved media parties and approval is at the discretion of the judiciary. Crown Court broadcasting of sentencing remarks built on the success of live streaming of cases from the Court of Appeal, which began in 2019. Most cases from the Court of Appeal (civil division) are live streamed on the judiciary’s YouTube channel.