Source · Select Committees · Justice Committee
Recommendation 3
3
Acknowledged
Karen Kneller's statements on report delays were problematic, requiring further clarification.
Conclusion
Karen Kneller’s statements on 29 April in relation to the version of the report sent to the CCRC by Chris Henley KC in January 2024 are problematic. Chris Henley KC was entitled to be concerned that Karen Kneller had wrongly suggested that he was somehow partly responsible for the delays in finalising the report. We welcome the clarifications provided by Karen Kneller in her letter on 20 May, but we regret that these were only provided because of Chris Henley KC’s further correspondence. (Conclusion, Paragraph 21) 43
Government Response Summary
The government acknowledges the committee's concerns about Karen Kneller's performance and evidence, noting her subsequent resignation on 2 July 2025, which they see as an opportunity to refresh CCRC leadership and restore confidence.
Government Response
Acknowledged
HM Government
Acknowledged
Your report refers to concerns regarding the performance of and evidence given to the Committee by the CCRC’s then Chief Executive, Karen Kneller. The report concluded that it was not tenable for her to continue in her position. Ms Kneller resigned from her role on 2 July 2025. This marks an opportunity for the CCRC to refresh its leadership and for confidence to be restored to the organisation. The Ministry of Justice will, as we do with all our public bodies, work constructively with and provide appropriate support to the interim Chief Executive, and the next permanent Chief Executive when appointed.