Recommendation 3

We acknowledge that steps have been taken towards greater transparency in the Care Act easement process, notably the publication of an updated list of local authorities using the easements; however, we believe this falls short of a proportionate level of transparency and accountability. The current process is not stringent enough to provide confidence that easements cannot be triggered for anything other than severe demand or resource issues caused by the pandemic. As such, it is impossible to scrutinise whether easements are being mis-used. We recommend guidance to local authorities on use of Care Act easements be updated to state that local authorities should keep a record of the reasons for their decisions and the anticipated effects on people and services, as set out in the current guidance but omitting the phrase “where possible”. Local authorities should in all circumstances keep such a record. We recommend the guidance be updated to state that local authorities should publish the information contained in the record prior to notification to the Department for Health and Social Care. We further recommend the guidance be updated to state explicitly that pre-emptive triggering of easements prior to publication of the decision record would be a misuse of the provisions, leaving local authorities open to legal challenge.