Source · Select Committees · Treasury Committee
Recommendation 2
2
Not Addressed
Paragraph: 41
We welcome the FCA’s approach to recruitment for some senior executive roles, which involved global...
Conclusion
We welcome the FCA’s approach to recruitment for some senior executive roles, which involved global searches, but we believe that the FCA was wrong not to have engaged in a fuller recruitment programme for the Executive Director for Transformation role, including the consideration of potential recruits from outside the FCA. It appears that there was a missed opportunity to consider fresh leadership for the Transformation programme. We also question whether there would have been a significant slowdown in the progress of the Transformation programme had Megan Butler not been recruited to oversee it. Another recruit might have been supported by Megan Butler for at least a period to help assist with this role, or Megan Butler might have taken on that role on a temporary basis whilst the recruitment process was conducted.
Government response summary AI-generated
The government response discusses the application of Senior Managers Regime principles to FCA senior managers and its impact on accountability and variable remuneration for control failings, but does not address the committee's specific criticism regarding the recruitment process for the Executive Director for Transformation role.
Summary of the government's response below — read the verbatim text to verify.
Paragraph Reference:
41
Government Response
Not Addressed
HM Government · verbatim extract
Not Addressed
The FCA takes a holistic approach when recruiting for all roles, but particularly for our critical roles. Once a position becomes vacant, we look at internal succession plans for all our Senior Leadership roles. Using these plans, we then assess who is immediately available with the appropriate skill set to cover for an interim period, as well as the strength and depth of our talent as we plan for a longer-term replacement. Where we are unable to fill a role from within the FCA on a temporary basis, we engage with the external market to bridge the gap while we undertake a full recruitment exercise. The duration of our interim arrangements is typically between six and 12 months to ensure a full search can be completed and the successful candidate brought onboard. All of our permanent appointments go through a robust recruitment process. In line with most other organisations, we conduct a mixture of internal-only recruitment, and exercises where we look both internally and externally. As I explained in my evidence to the Committee, transformation of the FCA is and has been a priority. I wanted to get things moving quickly and in order to do that, we chose to recruit an executive director for transformation from within the current executive team. This ensured stability and continuity during a period of considerable challenge (with successive lockdowns, end of the Brexit transition period and wider leadership change at the FCA) and allowed us to proceed with the wider restructuring of the FCA and launch campaigns for a range of other roles in parallel. This included the role of Chief Operating Officer, Chief Data, Information and Intelligence Officer and a number of other senior executive positions, which were run through global searches, internally and externally. The FCA Executive Committee now has ten members, six of whom have come from outside the FCA. Since October at Director level (the level immediately below the Executive Committee) in addition to promoting a number of our strongest internal leaders, we have also brought in significant new hires from outside the FCA, including a new Director, Digital and Intelligence, Chief Information Officer, Chief People Officer, Director of Environmental, Social and Governance and shortly a new Director of Communications. These new appointments bring a wealth of external operational, technological and commercial experience and this is balanced with the internal capability and institutional memory of longstanding FCA colleagues. I hope to continue to build an increasingly diverse team in the coming months and years.
Read the full response on Parliament ↗