Second Report: The impact of the coronavirus pandemic on the aviation sector

The government's response

What the committee recommended 23

1. 1
   The aviation sector is of huge strategic and economic importance to the UK. Conclusion · paragraph 15
2. 2
   We are concerned about the Government’s decision to introduce a blanket 14- day quarantine period... Conclusion · paragraph 27
3. 3
   In responding to this Report, the Government should clearly explain the reasons for its current... Recommendation · paragraph 28
4. 4
   The Government will be reassessing the quarantine policy in late June and it is right... Conclusion · paragraph 29
5. 5
   In order to allow the UK aviation industry to plan ahead, the Government should urgently... Recommendation · paragraph 30

See all 23 recommendations and conclusions

Sources

• Second Report: The impact of the coronavirus pandemic on the aviation sector ↗The committee's report, HC 268, parliament.uk
• Second Special Report - The impact of the coronavirus pandemic on the aviation sector: Government and Civil Aviation Authority Responses to the Committee’s Second Report ↗The government's response, 7 September 2020, parliament.uk

Recommendations and conclusions 23

1. 1
   The aviation sector is of huge strategic and economic importance to the UK. Conclusion · paragraph 15 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

   The aviation sector is of huge strategic and economic importance to the UK. The drastic reduction in air travel caused by the coronavirus pandemic has been devastating for the industry. Finding a proportionate way to steadily resume the number of flights while minimising the spread of coronavirus must be a priority for the UK Government.
2. 2
   We are concerned about the Government’s decision to introduce a blanket 14- day quarantine period... Conclusion · paragraph 27 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

   We are concerned about the Government’s decision to introduce a blanket 14- day quarantine period for travellers to the UK from other countries. This will further damage both the recovery of the aviation sector and the wider economy. We are not persuaded that a blanket quarantine policy is the right policy option at this time compared to the alternatives. We support a more targeted and nuanced border control policy that would allow people travelling from countries where the infection rate of Covid-19 is relatively low to enter the UK on a less restrictive basis.
3. 3
   In responding to this Report, the Government should clearly explain the reasons for its current... Recommendation · paragraph 28 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

   In responding to this Report, the Government should clearly explain the reasons for its current quarantine policy and the evidence base it used to make its decision.
4. 4
   The Government will be reassessing the quarantine policy in late June and it is right... Conclusion · paragraph 29 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

   The Government will be reassessing the quarantine policy in late June and it is right that preventing a second wave of the infection should be the utmost priority in determining next steps. Should the conditions allow in late June, we strongly urge the Government to introduce a more flexible and risk-based approach to border control and people entering the UK.
5. 5
   In order to allow the UK aviation industry to plan ahead, the Government should urgently... Recommendation · paragraph 30 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

   In order to allow the UK aviation industry to plan ahead, the Government should urgently update Parliament with detail about the key milestones and conditions that will need to be met for the current quarantine policy to be revised and ultimately ended.
6. 6
   Aviation is a global industry and there is a need for internationally agreed health standards... Recommendation · paragraph 34 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

   Aviation is a global industry and there is a need for internationally agreed health standards to minimise the risk to both passengers and workers from Covid-19. The UK has in the past led the way in the creation of global aviation standards and should do likewise for common health standards in light of the pandemic. In responding to this Report, the Government should set out what action it has taken at the international level to drive forward the development and implementation of global health standards for the aviation sector.
7. 7
   Given the gravity of the crisis in the aviation sector, we recommend that the UK... Recommendation · paragraph 47 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

   Given the gravity of the crisis in the aviation sector, we recommend that the UK Government implements support measures aimed specifically at the aviation sector in order to stimulate demand and protect businesses. In particular, we The impact of the coronavirus pandemic on the aviation sector 37 recommend that the UK Government and the devolved administrations (where they have not already done so) introduce a 12-month business rates relief for airlines and airports and a six-month temporary suspension of Air Passenger Duty payments.
8. 8
   Regional airports are vital to connect distant parts of the United Kingdom where no effective... Conclusion · paragraph 55 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

   Regional airports are vital to connect distant parts of the United Kingdom where no effective rail routes exist: Northern Ireland to Great Britain, and the UK’s nations and regions directly to other countries. The collapse of Flybe in March has unfortunately severely contracted regional air options across the UK. The sector-specific support we have recommended in respect of taxes on the aviation industry could help insulate regional airports from cost pressures.
9. 9
   We recommend the Department for Transport resume as a matter of urgency its review of... Recommendation · paragraph 56 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

   We recommend the Department for Transport resume as a matter of urgency its review of regional connectivity with a view to publication by the end of 2020.
10. 10
    The loss of some jobs in the aviation sector may sadly be inevitable. Recommendation · paragraph 64 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    The loss of some jobs in the aviation sector may sadly be inevitable. But such fundamental decisions about people’s livelihoods should not be made prematurely and until there is clearer information about the industry’s recovery. We urge UK- based aviation employers not to proceed hastily with largescale redundancies or restructuring to terms or conditions of employees until the Job Retention Scheme ends in October 2020 and they have had the opportunity to consider the Government’s plans to help the sector restart and recover.
11. 11
    Some redundancies at British Airways, as with other airlines, may be sadly inevitable in the... Conclusion · paragraph 80 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

    Some redundancies at British Airways, as with other airlines, may be sadly inevitable in the current crisis. Having questioned the Chief Executive of British Airways’ parent company and trade unions and received hundreds of submissions from British Airways employees, our view is that British Airways’ current consultation on staffing changes is a calculated attempt to take advantage of the pandemic to cut jobs and weaken the terms and conditions of its remaining employees. The behaviour of British Airways and its parent company towards its employees is a national disgrace. It falls well below the standards we would expect from any employer, especially in light of the scale of taxpayer subsidy, at this time of national crisis.
12. 12
    We urge British Airways to extend its consultation period to allow meaningful consultation to take... Recommendation · paragraph 81 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We urge British Airways to extend its consultation period to allow meaningful consultation to take place as per its legal requirements, and without pre-conditions, so that all parties can consider the proposed staffing changes in the context of the Government’s plans to help the aviation sector restart and recover.
13. 13
    The Government’s Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme was designed to help businesses affected by the pandemic... Recommendation · paragraph 82 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    The Government’s Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme was designed to help businesses affected by the pandemic to retain jobs and protect the economy. Some companies, such as British Airways, have proceeded with plans for large- scale redundancies while taking advantage of the scheme. This is regrettable. We recommend that the Government revise the rules of the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme to prevent, or strongly penalise, companies for making large- scale redundancies, while in receipt of funds from the taxpayer.
14. 14
    There have been calls from parliamentarians for the Government to strip British Airways from some... Recommendation · paragraph 83 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    There have been calls from parliamentarians for the Government to strip British Airways from some of its slots, especially from Heathrow Airport where it is the dominant airline. Given the global nature of slot allocation rules, and international legislative restrictions, there are clear limits on what the UK Government can do. However, there has been considerable structural and market change within the aviation industry as a result of the pandemic, including the consolidation of airlines at specific airports. These changes may go on for years and could have serious impacts on consumer choice. We recommend that the Department for Transport and the Civil Aviation Authority explore every avenue available to ensure that recent changes and their impact on the availability and distribution of airport slots do not unfairly impact passengers. This should include referring the whole aviation industry to the Competition and Markets Authority for a market study and possible investigation.
15. 15
    Many airlines and travel operators have failed to refund customers for package holidays and flights... Conclusion · paragraph 91 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

    Many airlines and travel operators have failed to refund customers for package holidays and flights in a timely manner, in accordance with their legal obligations. This is an understandable source of frustration for many customers who have found the process for obtaining monetary refunds unnecessarily difficult. People under stress because of the pandemic have faced additional stress because of companies who have not refunded their money properly and promptly.
16. 16
    The airline and travel industries are faced with an unprecedented crisis in which they have... Recommendation · paragraph 92 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    The airline and travel industries are faced with an unprecedented crisis in which they have been asked to refund billions of pounds worth of fares in a short period while also covering their extensive costs of operation. We recommend that before the Government brings forward its planned Airline Insolvency Bill, it consults on whether protections should be introduced for airline passengers in the event of pandemic or other extraordinary circumstances. Any changes should be incorporated into the Bill ideally before its introduction to Parliament or, failing that, during its parliamentary passage.
17. 17
    Airlines and travel operators have issued vouchers and credit notes as substitutes for cash refunds. Recommendation · paragraph 96 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    Airlines and travel operators have issued vouchers and credit notes as substitutes for cash refunds. Given that the viability of many airlines and package travel operators is sadly at risk due to the pandemic, the Government should provide reassurance to passengers by setting out clearly the circumstances under which a Refund Credit Note or a voucher issued by an airline is protected by the ATOL scheme.
18. 18
    The coronavirus pandemic has exposed weaknesses in the EU and UK regulations covering refunds for... Conclusion · paragraph 101 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

    The coronavirus pandemic has exposed weaknesses in the EU and UK regulations covering refunds for flights and package holidays. We have some sympathy with the view that the legal time limits for refunds should have been extended in the current circumstances, as occurred in some EU countries. In responding to this Report, the Department should clarify why an extension to the legal deadlines for issuing refunds was not implemented in the UK.
19. 19
    We note the Civil Aviation Authority’s concerns that the exercise of its current powers in... Recommendation · paragraph 102 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We note the Civil Aviation Authority’s concerns that the exercise of its current powers in relation to refunds can be difficult and take too long. They are also unable to impose financial penalties on operators who do not meet their obligations, The impact of the coronavirus pandemic on the aviation sector 39 unlike other regulators in the transport sector. We welcome the CAA’s review into how airlines are handling refunds during the coronavirus pandemic and look forward to its publication. We recommend that the Department and CAA conclude speedily a review of the CAA’s powers, to ensure that it can enforce the rights of passengers in an effective and timely way in future.
20. 20
    The Department has set up an Aviation Restart, Recovery, and Engagement Unit and the Minister... Conclusion · paragraph 108 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

    The Department has set up an Aviation Restart, Recovery, and Engagement Unit and the Minister told us she is devising a strategy to help the sector recover. While these moves are necessary and welcome, we are concerned at the lack of detail and pace of action given the precarious situation facing many airlines and the wider implications for the economy. In our view, the Government’s strategy for the recovery of the aviation sector should be more developed given we are already some four months into the crisis.
21. 21
    We recommend that the Department for Transport, working with other Government departments, the devolved administrations... Recommendation · paragraph 109 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We recommend that the Department for Transport, working with other Government departments, the devolved administrations and those within the industry, publishes a strategy for the restart and recovery of the aviation sector as soon as possible. This strategy must include details as to how the Department will rapidly restore passenger air travel and in particular set out plans to: • minimise job losses in the sector while protecting pay, employee rights and health and safety standards; • ensure passenger confidence with an internationally agreed standard of passenger health protection; • minimise disruption and complexity for passengers; • work on an international basis to re-examine the airport slot allocation process to ensure it encourages competition and connectivity; • assess the economic impact of reduced passenger services on the transport of air freight and examine the viability of alternatives, such as increasing the number of dedicated freight planes; • protect regional connectivity within the UK and international strategic trade links; and • ensure the industry delivers its environmental obligations. • We request that the Department provide a progress report to this Committee by 1 July 2020 on its strategy for the restart and recovery of the aviation sector.
22. 22
    We request that the Department provide a progress report to this Committee by 1 July... Conclusion · paragraph 110 · addressed to Department for Transport Conclusion (the committee's words)

    We request that the Department provide a progress report to this Committee by 1 July 2020 on its strategy for the restart and recovery of the aviation sector.
23. 23
    We recommend that, until the end of 2020, the Department commits to making a monthly... Recommendation · paragraph 111 · addressed to Department for Transport Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We recommend that, until the end of 2020, the Department commits to making a monthly written statement to Parliament, to update Members of both Houses on the work and key outcomes of the Aviation Restart, Recovery and Engagement Unit.