Fifth Report - Afghanistan: UK support for aid workers and the Afghan people

The government's response

What the committee recommended 24

1. 1
   We understand that the FCDO has reasons for clearly defining and limiting its liability in... Conclusion · paragraph 13
2. 2
   We believe that the FCDO should consider what moral obligations it has to aid sector... Recommendation · paragraph 14
3. 3
   We recommend that the FCDO take steps to better identify and assess the particular risks... Recommendation · paragraph 20
4. 4
   We were disappointed about the exclusion from the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP) scheme... Conclusion · paragraph 34
5. 5
   We call on the Government to accelerate without further delay all pathways of the Afghan... Recommendation · paragraph 35

See all 24 recommendations and conclusions

Sources

• Fifth Report - Afghanistan: UK support for aid workers and the Afghan people ↗The committee's report, HC 919, parliament.uk
• First Special Report - Afghanistan: UK support for aid workers and the Afghan people: Government response to the Committee’s Fifth Report of Session 2021–22 ↗The government's response, 19 May 2022, parliament.uk

Recommendations and conclusions 24

1. 1
   We understand that the FCDO has reasons for clearly defining and limiting its liability in... Conclusion · paragraph 13 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

   We understand that the FCDO has reasons for clearly defining and limiting its liability in respect of its contractual relationships with its external partners. However, we believe that events in Afghanistan have clearly illustrated that the Government’s policies should encompass much more than the legal aspects of duty of care as defined in its legal relationships with its suppliers and contactors.
2. 2
   We believe that the FCDO should consider what moral obligations it has to aid sector... Recommendation · paragraph 14 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   We believe that the FCDO should consider what moral obligations it has to aid sector workers who deliver UK aid and FCDO aims and objectives. We urge the FCDO to take a broader, more holistic view of its duty of care to people working in the aid sector.
3. 3
   We recommend that the FCDO take steps to better identify and assess the particular risks... Recommendation · paragraph 20 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   We recommend that the FCDO take steps to better identify and assess the particular risks facing aid workers so that it can respond more effectively to those aid workers when they are in need of support in countries or regions where there is acute instability or signs of a rapidly deteriorating security situation. FCDO staff in embassies in such countries should better communicate any signs of a potential deterioration in the security situation in country to those delivering UK aid programmes so that they can take appropriate steps to protect the safety of their staff.
4. 4
   We were disappointed about the exclusion from the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP) scheme... Conclusion · paragraph 34 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

   We were disappointed about the exclusion from the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy (ARAP) scheme of Afghan aid workers to whom the UK Government had clear lines of moral responsibility, either because they were sub- contracted by the UK Government or employed by aid agencies in receipt of UK aid. We are disappointed that Afghan aid workers have not been explicitly recognised in the Afghan Citizens Resettlement Scheme (ACRS). We are very concerned about the time being taken by the Government to implement the ACRS and whether Afghan aid workers will receive protection under that scheme.
5. 5
   We call on the Government to accelerate without further delay all pathways of the Afghan... Recommendation · paragraph 35 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   We call on the Government to accelerate without further delay all pathways of the Afghan Citizens Resettlement Scheme (ACRS) and ensure that aid sector staff are explicitly recognised and prioritised for protection under the ACRS.
6. 6
   The Government should not consider people evacuated under Operation Pitting under the Afghan Citizens Resettlement... Recommendation · paragraph 36 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   The Government should not consider people evacuated under Operation Pitting under the Afghan Citizens Resettlement Scheme (ACRS), instead it should consider those people under the Afghan Relocations and Assistance Policy scheme (ARAP) or other pre-existing pathways. The ACRS should be reserved for people: • located in Afghanistan; • located in third countries; • who have travelled to the UK, without UK Government assistance, from Afghanistan.
7. 7
   The Government should ensure transparency of reporting on the number of people resettled under the... Recommendation · paragraph 37 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   The Government should ensure transparency of reporting on the number of people resettled under the Afghan Citizens Resettlement Scheme (ACRS) by publishing a quarterly report on the number of people resettled under that scheme, publishing that first report by the end of June 2022.
8. 8
   We welcome the establishment of the Joint Afghanistan Casework Unit but note the lack of... Recommendation · paragraph 46 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   We welcome the establishment of the Joint Afghanistan Casework Unit but note the lack of clarity around the cost, staffing and current workload of that Unit. We are also concerned that more than three months after it was set up there is still no clarity on whether or not any of the costs of that Unit will be counted as UK ODA expenditure. We recommend that the Government: • establish targets for the performance of the Joint Afghanistan Casework Unit and report quarterly against those targets, publishing that first report by the end of June 2022; • report the number of cases involving people employed as aid workers that the Joint Afghanistan Casework Unit has taken receipt of, and report the status of those cases, by the end of June 2022; and • publish the costs of the Joint Afghanistan Casework Unit it attributes to the ODA budget.
9. 9
   We are very concerned about the time the Government has taken to disburse the UK... Recommendation · paragraph 58 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

   We are very concerned about the time the Government has taken to disburse the UK aid it has pledged to Afghanistan, given the considerable and escalating humanitarian need in the country. The Government should have worked faster to disburse the UK aid it pledged to Afghanistan in 2021.
10. 10
    We welcome the Government’s publication of 15 December 2021 showing details of the allocation and... Recommendation · paragraph 61 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We welcome the Government’s publication of 15 December 2021 showing details of the allocation and disbursal of the aid it has pledged to Afghanistan. We urge the Government to publish monthly updates on the allocation and disbursal of its aid to Afghanistan and to countries in the region.
11. 11
    We urge the FCDO to release more information on its Development Tracker web pages to... Recommendation · paragraph 62 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We urge the FCDO to release more information on its Development Tracker web pages to better ensure the transparency of reporting on the ODA funding it has allocated to projects in Afghanistan (if necessary, redacting parts of that information to mitigate any risks to safety and security).
12. 12
    We urge the FCDO to update information on all ODA allocations (for all countries) on... Recommendation · paragraph 63 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We urge the FCDO to update information on all ODA allocations (for all countries) on Development Tracker within a three-month period of those allocations having been made.
13. 13
    The Government has been far too slow to work with its international counterparts to find... Conclusion · paragraph 71 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

    The Government has been far too slow to work with its international counterparts to find ways to help unblock the banking system in Afghanistan. This has put at grave risk the delivery of humanitarian assistance to the people of Afghanistan. It is also deepening the humanitarian suffering of the people of Afghanistan.
14. 14
    The UK Government should be taking more urgent steps to collaborate with its international counterparts,... Recommendation · paragraph 72 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    The UK Government should be taking more urgent steps to collaborate with its international counterparts, economists, representatives of the banking sector and aid organisations to find ways to help address more rapidly the banking crisis in Afghanistan to ease the humanitarian suffering of, and enable the delivery of humanitarian assistance to, the people of Afghanistan.
15. 15
    We recognise the necessity of having to work with the Taliban. Conclusion · paragraph 77 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

    We recognise the necessity of having to work with the Taliban. We endorse the Government’s policy of developing a pragmatic working relationship with the Taliban to enable humanitarian aid to reach the people of Afghanistan.
16. 16
    We urge the Government to maintain its policy of working with the Taliban to enable... Recommendation · paragraph 78 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We urge the Government to maintain its policy of working with the Taliban to enable humanitarian aid to reach the people of Afghanistan.
17. 17
    We stand with the UK Government on seeking to ensure that the rights of women... Conclusion · paragraph 83 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

    We stand with the UK Government on seeking to ensure that the rights of women and girls are respected by the Taliban.
18. 18
    We call on the Government to ensure that it maintains its focus on working to... Recommendation · paragraph 84 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We call on the Government to ensure that it maintains its focus on working to try and ensure that the Taliban adopts a moderate position whereby it commits to behaving pragmatically towards the inclusion of women, girls and other minority groups in Afghan society.
19. 19
    We welcome the adoption of resolution 2615 at the UN Security Council on 22 December... Conclusion · paragraph 88 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

    We welcome the adoption of resolution 2615 at the UN Security Council on 22 December 2021, notwithstanding its limitations, and the UK Government’s adoption of that resolution into UK law.
20. 20
    We urge the UK Government to further step up its efforts on working with the... Recommendation · paragraph 89 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We urge the UK Government to further step up its efforts on working with the UN to ensure that aid organisations can effectively operate under the exemptions that UN resolution 2615 (and consequent UK law) permits. It should also urge the UN Security Council to extend those exemptions beyond their initial 12 months review period.
21. 21
    The UK Government should consult with representatives of aid organisations to ensure that it has... Conclusion · paragraph 90 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

    The UK Government should consult with representatives of aid organisations to ensure that it has issued adequate guidance on how to operate further to the adoption of UN resolution 2615 into UK law.
22. 22
    We welcome the UK’s participation in the Norwegian Government’s talks with the Taliban at the... Recommendation · paragraph 93 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We welcome the UK’s participation in the Norwegian Government’s talks with the Taliban at the end of January 2021. We call on the UK Government to press for UN resolution 2615 to be extended, or further resolutions to be adopted, to provide exemptions for development assistance, closely linked to the performance of the Taliban on upholding human rights and international law.
23. 23
    We welcome the steps the Government has taken to help free up the funds from... Conclusion · paragraph 99 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Conclusion (the committee's words)

    We welcome the steps the Government has taken to help free up the funds from the Afghanistan Reconstruction Trust Fund. However, the World Bank’s progress on releasing those funds has been agonizingly slow. Political and bureaucratic wrangling is impeding the release of over $1 billion already set aside for the Afghan people.
24. 24
    We ask the Government to do more to encourage the World Bank to swiftly release... Recommendation · paragraph 100 · addressed to Foreign, Commonwealth & Development Office Recommendation (the committee's words)

    We ask the Government to do more to encourage the World Bank to swiftly release the remaining funds from the Afghanistan Reconstruction Trust Fund so that aid organisations can use that money to provide humanitarian assistance to the people of Afghanistan.