Source · Select Committees · Foreign Affairs Committee

Recommendation 45

45 Acknowledged

Given the claimed economic impact of the sectoral agreements envisaged in the Common Understanding is...

Recommendation
Given the claimed economic impact of the sectoral agreements envisaged in the Common Understanding is larger than that of most Free Trade Agreements (FTAs), we recommend that the Government mirror the Department for Business and Trade’s commitments on transparency of FTA negotiations in current (and future) negotiations with the EU. This means it would publish, at a minimum, “Strategic Approaches” for the Sanitary and Phytosanitary Agreement, emissions trading systems linkage, electricity trading and youth mobility negotiations with the EU; conduct a Call for Evidence on each of these; as well as commit to publishing updates after each formal negotiating round with the EU. This would improve transparency of the negotiations, without providing a running commentary, and should enable key stakeholders to help inform the UK negotiating position in the current phase of the talks, and spot potential problems before the agreements are finalised. (Recommendation, Paragraph 120) 94
Government response summary AI-generated
The government states that it takes its commitment to scrutiny very seriously and is committed to being open and transparent in its engagement with Parliament, including through formal evidence sessions, correspondence and private briefings.
Summary of the government's response below — read the verbatim text to verify.
Government Response Acknowledged
HM Government · verbatim extract Acknowledged
The Government recognises the importance of engaging industry as part of the UK-EU negotiations process, and is committed to providing appropriate analysis of any agreement made with the EU, such as the food and drink agreement and the ETS linkage agreement. We are in regular dialogue with stakeholders through both formal TCA fora, like the Domestic Advisory Group and the Civil Society Forum, and departmental-led fora on specific thematic issues. DEFRA has recently published a Call for Information on the food and drink agreement to understand what information industry will need and the impact on their business in terms of benefits and costs associated with dynamic alignment with EU rules. Additionally, Ministers and officials regularly hold meetings with industry representatives to help test and further inform UK negotiating positions. As negotiations progress, the Government will follow normal processes for any necessary legislative changes, and assess impacts accordingly. We will not be able to provide a full assessment of the impacts whilst detailed negotiations are ongoing, but we have already taken steps to assess impacts. Combined, the food and drink and ETS linking measures alone are estimated to add up to £9 billion a year to the UK economy by 2040, in a significant boost for growth. Methodology notes for making this initial assessment have been published here (food and drink) and here (ETS). We are concerned about the evidence we have seen of potential shortcomings in the internal cross-Departmental coordination of the UK negotiating position with the EU, in particular between the Cabinet Office and Departments that hold responsibility for specific policy areas affected by the negotiations.
Read the full response on Parliament ↗