Source · Select Committees · Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee
Recommendation 6
6
Not Addressed
Paragraph: 32
We do, however, welcome the fact that the Government was willing to introduce temporary short-term...
Recommendation
We do, however, welcome the fact that the Government was willing to introduce temporary short-term visa schemes for the food and farming sector but it should learn the lessons from the operation and performance of these schemes and apply them to any similar schemes that are needed in the future. We recommend that the Government must conduct a comprehensive lessons learned exercise on the operation and performance of the temporary visa schemes. This must be informed by meaningful engagement with the sector. The Government should publish the result of this study before the end of July 2022.
Government response summary AI-generated
The government responded by discussing the importance of English language ability for workers, which was not the recommendation made.
Summary of the government's response below — read the verbatim text to verify.
Paragraph Reference:
32
Government Response
Not Addressed
HM Government · verbatim extract
Not Addressed
The Government introduced temporary visa schemes for poultry workers, food-sector HGV drivers, and pork butchers in recognition of the unique circumstances facing the food and farming sector due to global supply chain pressures. We listened to the concerns of the sector and acted to alleviate what was a very tight labour market in the lead up to Christmas 2021. These schemes were in addition to several skilled roles in these sectors, including butchers, already being eligible since January 2021 to apply to come to the UK through the Skilled Worker route as part of the Points Based System. The schemes were delivered as an emergency response to a number of short-term issues in the supply chain in the lead up to Christmas 2021 in the wake of the economy reopening post-pandemic, with Defra and the Home Office working closely to implement the schemes at pace. We utilised the existing framework of the Seasonal Worker route, which is a well-established route and has been subject to previous review, to successfully deliver these measures. There are no plans to undertake a formal lessons learned exercise for the temporary visa schemes. The scheme had a positive impact on food supply. As noted in the committee’s report, the poultry industry was able to access sufficient labour to meet peak Christmas trading demand in 2021 and credited the temporary visa scheme with this outcome. The reasons behind visa quotas not being met are likely to be complex and varied – including a decrease in the number of HGV drivers employed in other countries across the world during the pandemic and negative perceptions linked to pay and conditions. As the independent Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) outlined in their annual report from 2021, it could be that both sectors could do more to attract and retain British workers, particularly those who have not traditionally worked in those sectors, to help fill labour gaps. We have been clear that temporary visas are not a long-term solution to labour shortages, and that businesses must make investments in the UK domestic workforce and automation to reduce their reliance on migrant labour. The Government agrees with the MAC’s conclusions that “employers who are able to offer conditions that suit the greatest number of people are likely to be those who find it easiest to recruit staff.” The Government does not plan to re-introduce similar temporary visa schemes in the future. 4 Labour shortages in the food and farming sector: Government response
Read the full response on Parliament ↗