Select committee: Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee

Recommendation 15

Seventh Report - Food security Published 28 Jul 2023 Paragraph 66 Addressed to Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs
Recommendation (the committee's words)
We welcome steps by the Government to expand free school meal (FSM) eligibility. More children are receiving FSM than ever before in England, including all infant school children. However, there is evidence that extending FSM eligibility further could reap substantial benefits that outweigh the costs. The Government should, as a minimum, undertake a detailed study of the existing literature on the costs and benefits of extending FSM, which should as a minimum include extending FSM (a) for those children living in a Universal Credit claiming household, the impact of (i) raising the means-test to £20,000 post-tax income but before claiming benefits and (ii) removing the means-test and (b) universal provision. The Government should report its findings to the Committee within six months of the date of this report. In the meantime, the Government should urgently undertake a review with a view to increasing the household income threshold criteria for FSM from the current level of £7,400 (after tax and excluding benefits) so that more children living in poverty become eligible. To reduce the costs of extending FSM eligibility, the Government should consider the link between the FSM and the Pupil Premium for those children living in households above a certain income threshold.

From: Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Committee, Seventh Report - Food security (HC 622), paragraph 66, 28 July 2023

Government response

The government responded to the whole report on 17 November 2023 (deadline 28 September 2023).

Summary written by Accountability Index from the government's response. It is not the government's own words.

The government says it "takes all aspects of food security very seriously" but, across the report's recommendations, mostly points to existing measures and gives few new commitments, with some proposals declined or not planned.

  • On an annual UK Food Security Report, it says "We do not have plans to make the UKFSR an annual publication" and that the next report will be published by December 2024.
  • On the Cabinet Office review of food policy structures, it "agrees with the need for policy coherence and for strong leadership", but points to existing cross-Whitehall structures rather than committing to a review.
  • On free school meals, it says it does "not have plans to change the current eligibility conditions" but "will continue to keep eligibility under review"; on a sugar and salt tax, it does not consider "now is the right time".
  • On the Shropshire labour review, it is "currently considering the recommendations and intend[s] to publish a response before the end of the year".

Read the government's response ↗ Report an error